Home / Guides / St. Marks Guide / Restaurants / Categories / R.I.P.

R.I.P.

This category is for restaurants which are no longer open for business. I won't say that they've 'failed', rather they have simply 'moved on.'

These restaurants no longer exist! Do not bother trying to look for them!

I read in a book (The Collosus of New York) that you become a New Yorker the first time you say: "Hey, didn't that used to be a...?". If so, then I became a New Yorker the day I moved in to my apartment and noticed that the wonderful little French Cafe (The Blue Goose) across the street from school had been replaced by yet another sushi restaurant (*sigh*).

Ame Russe

R.I.P.
Good food, although expensive. This restaurant felt like you were stepping into a European bistro between the world wars.

Especially when they had this wonderful German singer (who must have stepped right out of Cabaret) singing with her accordian.  (2006-01-21)

2nd Avenue btwn St. Marks and 9th

The Kiev

R.I.P.
A Russian restaurant with wonderful salads, pierogi's, and martini's. This bar/restaurant was right next to our school so we ate here all the time.

Apparently, the Kiev used to be something of an East Village institution when it was a busy dive, but then after they renovated it no longer became popular. Currently it's open for drinks on occasion while looking for a new owner.  (2006-01-21)

2nd Avenue at 7th street

Into the woods

R.I.P.
A store, not a restaurant, selling various hand-crafted wood items from near and far. Items include wood bowls from India (I have one in my apartment), rough-hewn bird houses, various fancy wood screens, small wood cabinet knobs, etc.

I remember the owner/clerk being a grumpy old woman, and I thought to myself: "This is a *real* New Yorker." Bless her.  (2006-01-21)

St. Marks Place btwn 2nd and 3rd

New York Milkshake Company

R.I.P.
When I saw the bright yellow sign which just screams out "Milkshake Company", I thought for sure that I had died and gone to heaven. Unfortunately, the high prices (and my elevated LDL Cholesterol) were sufficient to dampen my enthusiasm.

That having been said, I still eat here about once every third week - especially when I'm feeling really low and I want to treat myself. Yes, the grilled cheese sandwiches are expensive ($5-7), but they're also really huge, so you don't feel too gyped. And on the whole the milkshakes are good ($4-7) - although occasionally they may have bits of ice in them, as if the icecream had been sitting in the freezer for too long.

PS: My sister really liked her Soy shake. But be sure to ask what the flavor is, there is only one and it changes.  (2005-09-12)

37 St. Marks Place (btw 2-3ave)
New York, NY 10003,USA
(212) 505-5200

Teresa's

Very good for family
An excellent family restaurant, Teresa's was packed with grandparents and grandchildren when I went, all speaking with very thick Eastern European accents. Just like in the movies!

The food is typical of East Village diner fare: roast chicken, meatloaf, soup, breakfast (all day), blintzes, pierogis, potato pancakes, etc. I had the tripe soup, green beans, salad, and meatloaf. The portions were generous and it was very inexpensive ($15 for the entire meal, including an ice tea). You can get a full dinner for under $10, easy. My only complaint was that the meatloaf was not as fluffy as I like (it was a denser, pressed meat variety) - but I'm just being picky because I happen to really like meatloaf.

Oh, and watch out for the restroom doors. Sometimes they stick shut.

Breakfast ($2-5), sandwiches ($4-6), burgers ($3.50-5), entrees ($8-9, includes two sides), deserts ($2-4).  (2006-01-30)

103 1st Ave (btwn 6th and 7th)
New York, NY 10003,USA
212-228-0604

Dojo

Only Fair but Inexpensive
When I first moved to the area, I thought Dojo would be fantastic. First off, it's pretty inexpensive, and second it's across the street. But after eating there a couple of times, I've just never gone back.

I've had the Chicken Don, Fish Tempura, Strawberry Lemonade, Salmon dinner, and the Gazpacho. Everything was fine, but nothing was very special. Except for the Gazpacho, which sould be avoided (if you want Gazpacho, go to Rueben's Empanadas on 1st Ave).

Burgers ($5), dinner salads ($4-5), appetizers and side salads ($2-5), soy burgers ($3-4), sandwiches ($2-4), Japanese specialities ($5-7), dinner platters ($5-9), beer ($3-4), wine ($4 per glass).  (2006-01-20)

24 St. Marks Place (btwn 2nd and 3rd ave)
New York, NY 10003,USA
212-674-9821

Flor's Kitchen

Very Good
Fun little hole-in-the-wall place serving Venezuelan and South American foods including Empanadas (4$), Arepas (5$), Ceviche ($10), and the best homemade flan I've ever tasted (but expensive, $7, it was on special).

The Ceviche was perhaps a bit small, but nice and tart and tasty (my glands are acting up just thinking about) with a incredible side of plantain chips.

Went back a second time and had the chicken dinner. Simple, but very good. An excellent place when you get tired of fancy, over-prepared foods.  (2006-01-07)

149 First Avenue (at 9th street)
New York, NY 10003,USA
212-229-9926

Good Dog

Unknown
Wow, this place opened and closed before I had a chance to eat here. And I really, really like hot dogs!  (2007-11-03)
St. Marks, btwn 2nd & 3rd
New York, NY, 10003,USA

Imagine

Good
Nice place, and right across the street from my (new) apartment. The food was good, but the problem was the restaurant just didn't have amy kind of "identity". There were foods from a miscellany of ethnic regions, and a nice bar, but it was all a little unfocussed. On well.  (2007-11-03)
114 1st Ave, btwn 6th & 7th
New York, NY 10003,USA

Share

Excellent
My favorite cuisine is an upscale, creative, American cuisine, and usually the more adventurous the better. I like it when the chef has the courage to experiment.

This is what Share is, and it's the only really nicer, American place in the St. Marks neighborhood I've found so far. The idea is that you share small plates of food and do wine tastings, in a more communal atmosphere. And it totally works. The wines are great and the food is always wonderfully prepared and very good. Highly recommend the risotto and the fish (have had several different types of both - always good). Avoid the oak leaf salad (too salty).

And yes, this was the place featured on Queer Eye for the Straight Guy, and you will likely see "Winston S.", the Maitre'D as you walk in the door. Check out Tom Filicia's design for the restaurant interior (beautiful).  (2005-09-14)

406 east 9th street (btwn 1st and A ave)
New York, NY 10009,USA
212-777-2425


This guide was created using SimpleReviewer.